Find Your Dream Home: Search 10,000+ Homes for Sale

458 Holly Avenue, Saint Paul, MN 55102

New Listing

$875,000

Nestled in the desirable Cathedral Hill neighborhood, this incredible home blends both old and new seamlessly.

Original teal tile is the focal point of the living room.

Breathtaking natural woodwork and another gas fireplace in the formal dining room.

Connect with family and guests in the eat-in kitchen with attached sitting room.

Custom-designed kitchen creates great flow in this exceptional renovation.

With the arched windows and stunning gas fireplace, the primary bedroom is filled with character.

Intricate woodwork on the railing adds character to the home.

Huge floor-to-ceiling windows fill the main level with natural light.

There is a large, open concept in the living areas.

There is plenty of space to relax and entertain in the main-floor family room.

Fun chalk board wall perfect for your "to do" list or cute family notes.

Keep your laundry out of site with a vintage door that has been retrofitted to slide with ease.

The cozy sitting room off of the kitchen island is ideal for entertaining or morning coffee.

Laundry is a breeze in this beautiful main-floor laundry room.

Keep everything organized with a custom designed mud room.

The main-floor bathroom has a vintage flair with the convenience of a shower on this level.

Head upstairs to find four large bedrooms and two more full bathrooms.

Relax in the cozy sitting area in the primary bedroom.

Too many clothes? No worries, there is a wall of closets in the primary bedroom.

A full four-piece bathroom with claw-foot tub and huge walk-in shower on the second floor.

Another full bathroom on the second floor.

More floor-to-ceiling windows fill this home with natural light.

The large back bedroom spans the width of the home.

This bedroom doubles as a private family room.

The fourth bedroom also features stunning windows and gleaming hardwood floors.

The multiple patio spaces, minimize yard work.

The private back patios are the perfect place to relax and enjoy Minnesota summers.

The original cellar door offers direct access to the basement to store your seasonal furniture, bicyles and more.

The laundry and mudroom addition blends perfectly with the original home.

The two-car garage with concrete driveway can also provide additional guest parking.

The Cathedral Hill neighborhood is rich with historic architecture and urban parks.

The stunning design of the W.A. Frost building.

Cochran Park is the perfect spot for a summer picnic.

You can walk to the neighborhood's favorite breakfast spot the French Hen.

Looking for a burger and a drink? You will love the Red Rabbit.

Mississippi Market is just footsteps away!

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 4 Baths: 3 Square Footage: 4,478 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 5,663 Status: Active

Current Price: $875,000 List Date: 6/24/2026 Last Modified: 6/25/2026

Overview

Description

Welcome to 458 Holly Avenue, a striking Victorian built in 1888, set on one of the most beautiful blocks in Saint Paul’s historic Cathedral Hill neighborhood. From the moment you step inside, you’ll feel the balance: original character in all the right places—wide archways, tall sun-filled windows, rich natural woodwork, and multiple fireplaces—paired with updates that make daily life seamless. At the heart of the home is a stunning designer kitchen, perfectly scaled for both everyday living and entertaining. It opens effortlessly to a comfortable family room—creating the kind of connected, functional space buyers are looking for—while still honoring the home’s historic charm. A rare and highly practical main level layout also includes a mudroom, laundry, office, and ¾ bath. Upstairs, four bedrooms and two full bathrooms on one level offer flexibility and convenience, anchored by a romantic primary suite featuring distinctive windows, beautiful woodwork, its own gas fir ... (Read more)

Open Houses

Tomorrow, 10:00 am - 1:00 pm

Listing Details MLS# 7095777

General Property Information

Common Wall: No
Lot Measurement: Acres
Manufactured Home?: No
Multiple PIDs?: No
New Development: No
Number of Fireplaces: 3
Waterfront YN: No
Year Built: 1888
Yearly/Seasonal: Yearly
Zoning: Residential-Single Family
Bath Full: 2
Bath Three Quarters: Yes
Main Floor Total SqFt: 1589
Above Grd Total SqFt: 2889
Below Grd Total SqFt: 1589
Total SqFt: 4478
Total Finished Sqft: 2889.00
FireplaceYN: Yes
Style: (SF) Single Family
Foundation Size: 1589
Garage Stalls: 2
Lot Dimensions: 40x144
Acres: 0.13
Assessment Pending: Yes
Bath Half: 0
Bath Quarter: 0
Association Fee: 0

Property Features

Accessible: None Air Conditioning: Central Air Amenities Unit: Ceiling Fan(s); Deck; Hardwood Floors; In-Ground Sprinkler; Kitchen Center Island; Kitchen Window; Porch; Tile Floors Appliances: Cooktop; Double Oven; Dryer; Refrigerator; Washer Assumable Loan: Not Assumable Basement: Full Bath Description: Main Floor 3/4 Bath; Upper Level Full Bath; Separate Tub & Shower; Walk-In Shower Stall Construction Materials: Stone Construction Status: Previously Owned Dining Room Description: Eat In Kitchen; Separate/Formal Dining Room Electric: Circuit Breakers Existing Financing: Conventional Exterior: Wood Family Room Characteristics: Family Room; Main Level Fencing: Full; Wood; Other Fireplace Characteristics: Decorative; Family Room; Gas Burning; Primary Bedroom Foundation: Stone Fuel: Natural Gas Heating: Forced Air Laundry: Laundry Room; Main Level Lot Description: Public Transit (w/in 6 blks) Road Frontage: City Street Roof: Age 8 Years or Less; Asphalt Shingles Sellers Terms: Cash; Conventional Sewer: City Sewer/Connected Special Search: 4 BR on One Level; Main Floor Laundry Stories: Two Water: City Water/Connected

Contract Information

Contingency: None
Original List Price: 875000
ListPrice: 875000
Owner is an Agent?: No
Auction?: No

Location Tax and Other Information

House Number: 458
Street Name: Holly
Street Suffix: Avenue
Postal City: Saint Paul
County: Ramsey
State: MN
Zip Code: 55102

Assessments

Assessment Balance: 216
Tax With Assessments: 16320

Building Information

Finished SqFt Above Ground: 2889

More Information

Lease Details

Land Leased: Not Applicable

Miscellaneous Information

Homestead: No

Ownership

Fractional Ownership: No

Parking Characteristics

Garage Square Feet: 440

Public Survey Info

Range#: 23
Section#: 01
Township#: 28

Office/Member Info

Association: SPAAR

Location, Tax and Other Information

AssocFeeYN: No
Legal Description: SUBDIVISION OF BLOCKS 19 21 A E 4O FT OF LOT 21 BLK 19
Listing City: Saint Paul
Map Page: 108
Municipality: Saint Paul
School District: St. Paul
School District Phone: 651-767-8100
Zip Plus 4: 2206
Property ID Number: 012823240157
Tax Year: 2026
Tax Amount: 16104
In Foreclosure?: No
Potential Short Sale?: No
Lender Owned?: No

Directions & Remarks

Public Remarks: Welcome to 458 Holly Avenue, a striking Victorian built in 1888, set on one of the most beautiful blocks in Saint Paul’s historic Cathedral Hill neighborhood. From the moment you step inside, you’ll feel the balance: original character in all the right places—wide archways, tall sun-filled windows, rich natural woodwork, and multiple fireplaces—paired with updates that make daily life seamless. At the heart of the home is a stunning designer kitchen, perfectly scaled for both everyday living and entertaining. It opens effortlessly to a comfortable family room—creating the kind of connected, functional space buyers are looking for—while still honoring the home’s historic charm. A rare and highly practical main level layout also includes a mudroom, laundry, office, and ¾ bath. Upstairs, four bedrooms and two full bathrooms on one level offer flexibility and convenience, anchored by a romantic primary suite featuring distinctive windows, beautiful woodwork, its own gas fireplace, and generous closet space. The bathrooms have been tastefully updated to complement the home’s character while delivering modern comfort. All of this, just steps from the charm and vibrancy of Selby and Grand Avenue—restaurants, shops, cafes, and neighborhood favorites—making this not just a beautiful home, but an exceptional lifestyle opportunity.
Directions: From Summit Avenue go north on Arundel to Holly, and west (left) on Holly to home.

Accessible

None: Yes

Air Conditioning

Central Air: Yes

Amenities Unit

Ceiling Fan(s): Yes
Deck: Yes
Hardwood Floors: Yes
In-Ground Sprinkler: Yes
Kitchen Center Island: Yes
Kitchen Window: Yes
Porch: Yes
Tile Floors: Yes

Appliances

Cooktop: Yes
Double Oven: Yes
Dryer: Yes
Refrigerator: Yes
Washer: Yes

Assumable Loan

Not Assumable: Yes

Basement

Full: Yes

Bath Description

Main Floor 3/4 Bath: Yes
Upper Level Full Bath: Yes
Separate Tub & Shower: Yes
Walk-In Shower Stall: Yes

Construction Materials

Stone: Yes

Construction Status

Previously Owned: Yes

Dining Room Description

Eat In Kitchen: Yes
Separate/Formal Dining Room: Yes

Electric

Circuit Breakers: Yes

Existing Financing

Conventional: Yes

Exterior

Wood: Yes

Family Room Characteristics

Family Room: Yes
Main Level: Yes

Fencing

Full: Yes
Wood: Yes
Other: Yes

Fireplace Characteristics

Decorative: Yes
Family Room: Yes
Gas Burning: Yes
Primary Bedroom: Yes

Foundation

Stone: Yes

Fuel

Natural Gas: Yes

Heating

Forced Air: Yes

Insurance Fee

Insurance Fee: 0

Laundry

Laundry Room: Yes
Main Level: Yes

Lot Description

Public Transit (w/in 6 blks): Yes

Patio, Porch and Deck Features

Front Porch: Yes
Patio: Yes

Road Frontage

City Street: Yes

Roof

Age 8 Years or Less: Yes
Asphalt Shingles: Yes

Sellers Terms

Cash: Yes
Conventional: Yes

Sewer

City Sewer/Connected: Yes

Special Search

4 BR on One Level: Yes
Main Floor Laundry: Yes

Stories

Two: Yes

Water

City Water/Connected: Yes

Room Information

Room Name	Dimensions	Level
Dining Room	15.2x13.2	Main
Family Room	22.2x16.10	Main
First (1st) Bedroom	18.9x13.11	Upper
Fourth (4th) Bedroom	12.2x10.2	Upper
Foyer	7.1x8.1	Main
Kitchen	21.4x15.5	Main
Laundry	8.3x9.10	Main
Living Room	14.8x14.3	Main
Mud Room	10.2x9.10	Main
Second (2nd) Bedroom	18.9x12	Upper
Sitting Room	9.4x11	Main
Third (3rd) Bedroom	13.1x13.2	Upper

Documents

Floor plans ›

Listing Office: Edina Realty, Inc.

Last Updated: June - 25 - 2026

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity SM Program of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc. The information provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Properties subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. ©2024 Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc All rights reserved.